‘Five for Sorrow, Ten for Joy’ by Rumer Godden #TuesdayBookBlog #BookReview


Amazon.co.uk   Amazon.com

The Sisters of Béthanie, a French order of Dominican nuns, dedicate themselves to caring for the outcasts of society – criminals, prostitutes and drug addicts. Lise, an English girl who after the liberation of Paris was employed in one of the city’s smartest brothels and rose to become a successful madame, finds herself joining the Sisters. Master storyteller Rumer Godden weaves a deeply moving tale of Lise’s prison sentence, her conversion and the agonising work among women whose traumatic experiences often outstrip even her own.

I’ve always loved Virago – when I was younger and discovering lots of women writers, the Virago stand in my local bookshop was the go-to place for me on a Saturday morning (what a nerd I was), but I have never read anything by Rumer Godden. So when this was recommended to me, I was very curious. I have to admit though, that the subject matter really didn’t appeal. I’m an atheist and I have little time at all for religion. I’d far rather sit down and read some Christopher Hitchens than a book about nuns, but I decided to give this one a try.

I’m very glad I did, although I did have some difficulty with the subject matter. Lise is a Sister of Bethanie, dedicated to caring for the outcasts, for prisoners, drug addicts, prostitutes, the lowest of the low. Through extremely clever structuring, we move back and forth through her life and learn how she became a nun, her past as a prostitute,  and why that happened to her.

We also learn a great deal about the life of a nun, of the daily, weekly and monthly routines. This was very interesting and insightful and not at all dull to read, because Godden’s prose is absolutely stunning. And this is why I can set aside any misgivings about the subject matter – the book is a joy to read because of the sheer beauty of the writing. I felt as though I truly knew Lise. The portrayals of other characters, particularly Vivi, are striking and compelling to read. There is no judgement here, and no judgement from the nuns either and this felt more like a book about people, than about religion.

This is one of those books that you can’t wait to get back to. I’ll definitely be reading more by this author.

5 stars



  1. I have many of Rumer Godden’s works including two volumes of autobiography which are fascinating accounts of living in India. Black Narcissus is another novel about nuns. It was made into a film, which Rumer hated. Greengage Summer is set in France – a wonderful coming of age novel. I could go on and on – do read more of her. Her daughter lives not so far from me and I interviewed her a few years ago for a feature on her mother.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. My all-time favourite Rumrt Godden novel is The Battle for (of?) the Villa Fiorita – about the aftermath of parents’ separation from the point of view of the children. – It is a story that has remained with me and which I have re-read several times and now sadly have lent to someone who hasn’t given it back, and as I’m not sure who I can’t reclaim it.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I would like to read more Rumer Godden. Thanks for the nudge. The only Rumer Godden book I’ve read is The Mousewife. That book is absolutely stunning. I read it again and again and often use it with students. I recommend The Mousewife if you have any youngsters on your holiday gift list.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s